General

A bmi of 50 or more

According to Chat-GPT, only 0.25% of the US population has a BMI of 50 or more. I seriously thought that it was way more than that lol. I'd have to be over 400lbs to hit that BMI, but I think that's going to have to be my goal lol.
4 days

A bmi of 50 or more

Jakeescape99:
According to Chat-GPT, only 0.25% of the US population has a BMI of 50 or more. I seriously thought that it was way more than that lol. I'd have to be over 400lbs to hit that BMI, but I think that's going to have to be my goal lol.


Thus is a beautiful example of why you should not use Chat-GPT for research.

The highest BMI category the CDC and the NIH track is 40 or more - which is severe obesity. This is a little over 9% of the US population. There's no tracking for Americans with a BMI of 50% or more.

In other words, Chat-GPT hallucinated this information.
4 days

A bmi of 50 or more

Jakeescape99:
According to Chat-GPT, only 0.25% of the US population has a BMI of 50 or more. I seriously thought that it was way more than that lol. I'd have to be over 400lbs to hit that BMI, but I think that's going to have to be my goal lol.

Munchies:
Thus is a beautiful example of why you should not use Chat-GPT for research.

The highest BMI category the CDC and the NIH track is 40 or more - which is severe obesity. This is a little over 9% of the US population. There's no tracking for Americans with a BMI of 50% or more.

In other words, Chat-GPT hallucinated this information.


Chat gpt will give its sources if you ask sometimes. It might not be hallucinated, it also might not be accurate. Although I don’t know how reliable CDC/NIH data is going forward, either. Might be an issue by issue thing.
4 days

A bmi of 50 or more

Jakeescape99:
According to Chat-GPT, only 0.25% of the US population has a BMI of 50 or more. I seriously thought that it was way more than that lol. I'd have to be over 400lbs to hit that BMI, but I think that's going to have to be my goal lol.

Munchies:
Thus is a beautiful example of why you should not use Chat-GPT for research.

The highest BMI category the CDC and the NIH track is 40 or more - which is severe obesity. This is a little over 9% of the US population. There's no tracking for Americans with a BMI of 50% or more.

In other words, Chat-GPT hallucinated this information.

Letters And Numbers:
Chat gpt will give its sources if you ask sometimes. It might not be hallucinated, it also might not be accurate. Although I don’t know how reliable CDC/NIH data is going forward, either. Might be an issue by issue thing.


Feel you on the CDC/NIH, but the point still stands. When it comes to tracking BMIs, the highest they go is a BMI of 40 or more. There is no data of 50 or more. I checked before I posted.
4 days

A bmi of 50 or more

Jakeescape99:
According to Chat-GPT, only 0.25% of the US population has a BMI of 50 or more. I seriously thought that it was way more than that lol. I'd have to be over 400lbs to hit that BMI, but I think that's going to have to be my goal lol.

Munchies:
Thus is a beautiful example of why you should not use Chat-GPT for research.

The highest BMI category the CDC and the NIH track is 40 or more - which is severe obesity. This is a little over 9% of the US population. There's no tracking for Americans with a BMI of 50% or more.

In other words, Chat-GPT hallucinated this information.

Letters And Numbers:
Chat gpt will give its sources if you ask sometimes. It might not be hallucinated, it also might not be accurate. Although I don’t know how reliable CDC/NIH data is going forward, either. Might be an issue by issue thing.


LLMs always hallucinate, even when the responses they give are accurate.

Its not about the results, though those provide hints, its about the way they function, that is LLMs work purely on statistics and not some kind of rule-based system.

They sometimes deliver correct responses, yes, but even a broken clock is right twice a day!

In other words, you can arrive at a correct conclusion through hallucinating, there is no reason for which you can't, its just that there are far better ways to reach conclusions.
4 days

A bmi of 50 or more

Munchies:
In other words, Chat-GPT hallucinated this information.

+1
4 days

A bmi of 50 or more



Munchies:
Feel you on the CDC/NIH, but the point still stands. When it comes to tracking BMIs, the highest they go is a BMI of 40 or more. There is no data of 50 or more. I checked before I posted.



I just asked it the same question and to cite sources, and it gave a much clearer answer than the OP received, citing national data for BMI >40 (with sources, just like you said) and a 2010 study on NIH’s website (that relied on self reporting) that did categorize BMI >50, which is where that less than 1% figure might have HR have come from. ChatGPT admitted that the data is unreliable because of sample size and self reporting. All in all, more useful than an open query. I always ask for links when I’m using it like a search engine. You can see the context of the response.
4 days

A bmi of 50 or more



Munchies:
Feel you on the CDC/NIH, but the point still stands. When it comes to tracking BMIs, the highest they go is a BMI of 40 or more. There is no data of 50 or more. I checked before I posted.

Letters And Numbers:
I just asked it the same question and to cite sources, and it gave a much clearer answer than the OP received, citing national data for BMI >40 (with sources, just like you said) and a 2010 study on NIH’s website (that relied on self reporting) that did categorize BMI >50, which is where that less than 1% figure might have HR have come from. ChatGPT admitted that the data is unreliable because of sample size and self reporting. All in all, more useful than an open query. I always ask for links when I’m using it like a search engine. You can see the context of the response.


Links are always superior. Imo, it's better to develop keyword searches and read the information yourself. Still, I do appreciate that you take the time to look it up on your end rather than blindly trusting whatever result pops up in Chat-GPT.
4 days

A bmi of 50 or more

I don’t think bmi is an indicator of much, given how few conditions I have relative to what I should have given my bmi is 76
4 days

A bmi of 50 or more

Morbidly A Beast:
I don’t think bmi is an indicator of much, given how few conditions I have relative to what I should have given my bmi is 76


From what I gather from OP, he's more interested in size than any complications.
4 days
12   loading